Skip to main content

Sowing Slogans

MSP is important, but real issues are markets, first-stage processing and supply chains.

MSP is important, but real issues are markets, first-stage processing and supply chains
X
In any case, the MSPs effectively matter for and cover only a few crops, and that too in a few regions. (Representational)
We seem to be in an anything-goes frame. In these columns, I had argued that the MET department’s forecast of a “normal” monsoon was with the rider of expected problems in the Deccan Plateau. Unfortunately, I turned out to be right.
By June 27, the country had a more than 10 per cent deficiency and the monsoon had barely reached central India. By July 3, the deficiency was seven per cent and the MET department is saying with some satisfaction that the kharif rainfall is normal as they had predicted. Senior officials and some of the financial press, not to ignore politicians, are predicting a normal kharif harvest.
But a meteorological “normal” need not be an agricultural “normal”. Delayed rains in dry and rainfed areas can mean delayed sowing. Sometimes, a less preferred crop has to be sown. We are happy at the farmer sowing oilseed or pulses but he wants to sow paddy. Until the first week of July, and well past the sowing season, Gujarat and Saurashtra, UP, central Bihar, Odisha and the entire Northeast were deficient in rainfall. This is not to be scoffed at. Remedial steps must be taken.
Niti Aayog officials have correctly pointed out that the MSP is 50 per cent higher than paid out costs in most crops. Others say that was not the recommendation of the National Commission on Farmers. This is turning into a “tu tu mein mein” match. Rajiv Kumar and Ramesh Chand, both economists of impeccable integrity and competence, have argued correctly that in economic theory, rentals on land and return to capital are not always compensated in short-run pricing decisions. But our government does not follow Ricardian principles in its economic policies.
In calculations of controlled item prices or for public sector purchases, or for that matter, for setting tariff rates for domestic protection, land rentals and return to capital is included in cost. It’s the CA who is calling the shots and not economic theory. So, what’s good for the goose should be good for the gander.
I had in one of my books worked out a long-run tariff example and in that had not costed scarcity rentals and abnormal interest rates. But sadly, that example is only used for teaching. So M S Swaminathan is on firm ground in saying that the 50 per cent recommended is on C2 costs and not A2 plus family labour costs. The former includes imputed rental and capital costs. Incidentally, it is wrong to say that transport and sales costs are excluded, as some farm leaders are saying. A committee I chaired a number of years ago had recommended that the time the farmer spends on taking the crop to the mandi and the transport cost should be included in C2 costs. My impression is that has been done.
In any case, the MSPs effectively matter for and cover only a few crops, and that too in a few regions. Also, there is only token procurement in pulses and oilseeds because the prices the farmer has sown for are much higher. The farmer knows when he plants a dal that he will not get the then prevailing price of over Rs 200 a quintal and will settle for Rs 150. The MSP of Rs 50 or Rs 60 is not important and in any case he is worried about highly subsidised imports from the US, Canada or Australia. The government hardly ever imposes a high enough tariff because of the needs of the consumer.
NAFED does some procurement, but it is usually short of funds. In reality, therefore, the MSP is a peg to base slogans on. The real issue of markets, first-stage processing and supply chains lies elsewhere. Getting Walmart to buy farmers’ produce and give them space in its warehouses is important to give the farmer another supply chain. But we are told its case is slowed down because of the trader lobby. In pulses, vegetables, fruit and milk, demand is rising fast and where we get food and agri inflation, the infrastructure has yet to be built.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

तापमान को प्रभावित करने वाले कारक – FACTORS AFFECTING TEMPERATURE

  आज हम तापमान (temperature) को प्रभावित करने वाले कारकों (factors) की चर्चा करेंगे. किसी क्षेत्र का तापमान क्यों अधिक और क्यों कम होता है, इस बात को हम इस आर्टिकल के द्वारा समझने की कोशिश करेंगे. यदि किसी क्षेत्र का तापमान अधिक है तो इसका साफ़ मतलब होता है कि वहाँ बहने वाली वायु गर्म है. इसलिए क्यों न हम ये जानें कि वायु का तापक्रम किन चीजों से प्रभावित होता है? पृथ्वी के विभिन्न भागों में वायु के तापक्रम पर प्रभाव डालने वाली प्रमुख बातें निम्नलिखित हैं  – अक्षांश (Latitude) पृथ्वी की उभरी हुई गोलाई के कारण उस पर सभी जगह एक-सी सूर्य की किरणें नहीं पड़तीं. कहीं वे सीधी पड़ती हैं और कहीं तिरछी. सीधी किरणों की अपेक्षा तिरछी किरणें अधिक क्षेत्र में फैलती हैं, फलतः उनसे पृथ्वी पर कम गर्मी उत्पन्न होती है और उसके सम्पर्क में आने वाली वायु कम गर्म हो पाती है. इस चित्र में विषुवतीय (Equator) रेखा पर सूर्य की सीधी किरणें पड़ रही हैं और ध्रुवों पर तिरछी. ध्रुवों के पास अपेक्षाकृत अधिक क्षेत्र में किरणें फैलती हैं. साथ ही, विषुवत् रेखा (equator) पर सूर्य की किरणों को वायुमंडल का कम भाग...

पूर्वोत्तर (शीतकालीन) मानसून क्या है? NORTHEAST MONSOON IN HINDI

  पूर्वोत्तर मानसून   (northeast monsoon) अर्थात् शीतकालीन मानसून पिछले दिनों समाप्त हुआ. इस बार कुल मिलाकर इस समय औसत से अधिक वृष्टिपात हुआ. एक बड़ी विरल घटना यह हुई कि जिस दिन  दक्षिण-पश्चिम का मानसून  समाप्त हुआ, उसी दिन शीतकालीन मानसून चालू हुआ. पूर्वोत्तर (शीतकालीन) मानसून क्या है? उत्तर भारत के लोग इस मानसून के बारे में कम जानते हैं. परन्तु यह मानसून भारतीय उपमहाद्वीप की जलवायु प्रणाली का उतना ही स्थायी अंग है जितना कि ग्रीष्मकालीन अर्थात् दक्षिण-पश्चिम मानसून. भारत मौसम विज्ञान विभाग (India Meteorological Department – IMD) के अनुसार पूर्वोत्तर मानसून  अक्टूबर से दिसम्बर  तक चलता है. इस अवधि में तमिलनाडु, केरल और आंध्र प्रदेश के साथ-साथ तेलंगाना और कर्नाटक के कुछ भागों में वृष्टिपात होता है. पूर्वोत्तर और दक्षिण-पश्चिम मानसून में अंतर जैसा कि नाम से ही पता चलता है कि पूर्वोत्तर मानसून की दिशा पूर्वोत्तर से दक्षिण-पश्चिम होती है. उसी प्रकार दक्षिण-पश्चिम मानसून की दिशा इसके ठीक उल्टी अर्थात् दक्षिण-पश्चिम से पूर्वोत्तर होती है. पूर्वोत्तर मानसून कब आता ...

Todays Current Affairs (14.08.2019)

Sri Lanka flags off Pulathisi Express, a 'Make In India' train The strong ties between India and its southern neighbor Sri Lanka received a boost when a newly 'Make In India' train rake was flagged of from Colombo Fort Railway station. The rake of Pulathisi Express was manufactured in the Integral Coach Factory (ICF) in Chennai. Sri Lankan President Maithripala Sirisena, Transport Minister Arjuna Ranathunga and Indian envoy to Sri Lanka Taranjit Singh Sandhu flagged off a new train to Polonnaruwa from Colombo Fort Railway station. India hosts the first conference on military medicine for SCO member nations India is hosting the first conference on military medicine for member nations of the Shanghai Co-operation Organisation in New Delhi. The two-day conference is being held with an aim to share best practices in the field of military medicine. Union Defence Minister Rajnath Singh attended the conference. This is the first military co-operation event ...